Amish matchmaker mystery Books in Order

Humor & SatireMystery & Detective

Rate this series:

🎧 Listen to Matchmaking Can Be Murder on Audible

Amanda Flower's 'Amish Matchmaker series' (e.g., 'Matchmaking Can Be Murder', 2020) differs from the TPL's 'Amish matchmaker mystery' series (e.g., 'Dating Can Be Deadly', 2023). No matching series found in bm2.

✓ All 3 books verified against the publisher's official series list.

Books in this series

Ordered by first publication where known. The official numbering for this series is incomplete in our sources, so we don't show series numbers we can't verify.

  1. Matchmaking Can Be Murder

    2019

    Matchmaking can be murder . . . When widowed Millie Fisher moves back to her childhood home of Harvest, Ohio, she notices one thing right away—the…

    Read more →
    Buy on Amazon
  2. Cover of Dating Can Be Deadly

    Dating Can Be Deadly

    2023 · Flower, Amanda

    It's August in Holmes County, and that means it's time for the Holmes County Fair. It's the county’s biggest annual event, drawing tourists and…

    Read more →
    Buy on Amazon
  3. Cover of Newlyweds Can Be Knocked Off

    Newlyweds Can Be Knocked Off

    2025 · Flower, Amanda

    After years on her own, Millie has been busy adjusting to married life once again. Meanwhile, her best friend, Lois Henry, is still salty that Millie…

    Read more →
    Buy on Amazon

Frequently asked questions

What order should I read the Amish matchmaker mystery books in?

Read them in publication order — the list above is sorted by first publication where known, starting with “Matchmaking Can Be Murder”.

How many books are in the Amish matchmaker mystery series?

We list 3 books by Flower, Amanda , published between 2019–2025.

Where can I buy the Amish matchmaker mystery books?

Each title above links to Amazon. See our affiliate disclosure.

Reading order compiled from author/publisher guidance and verified bibliographic data. Spotted a wrong order, a missing book, or any other mistake? and we'll correct it.